trC_climbgarden

Status: Denied

Reason:

- there is nothing wrong with the map "overall" but there is still alot of bugs and things you can fix if you want to. im gonna post the bugs we found.

- bugs: (radon)
http://www.rad0n.dk/trc1.bmp : bad mapping
http://www.rad0n.dk/trc2.bmp : bad mapping
http://www.rad0n.dk/trc3.bmp : repitive texture.
http://www.rad0n.dk/trc4.bmp : add another texture to the sides on the ladder.
http://www.rad0n.dk/trc5.bmp : water surface while your underwater ? remove it.
http://www.rad0n.dk/trc6.bmp : that structure looks very strange. fix the flat side.

- the map is still alittle short, but its not a big problem! u can keep it as it is now.

- bugs: (NumB)
* Add shadows from walls what separate rooms - will look more realistic.
* Invisible wall or what?
* Invisible wall or what?
* Add wall [black] (took time to find that passage) and remove that block [red] - doesn't fit there.
* Null bug.
* Null bug (tree at the start).
* Sc (and 3 ways how to do it).
* Sc (and two ways how to do it) (however I like this one and it doesn't save that much).
* Sc (this is a continue of last sc) (this one saves really much).
* Sc (hard but looks possible).
* Sc (hard but looks possible for cj some g33k).
* Slide-stuck (you can slide from it but it takes much time if you'r ducked) (at the start).
* Slide-stuck.
* Texture problem (shadows from nowhere?).

- bugs: (demolite)
cartoon textures with realtextures mixed aren't good
http://demolite.climbers-germany.de/mapcheck/trc_climbgarden/shadow_thing.jpg : Shadow bug
http://demolite.climbers-germany.de/mapcheck/trc_climbgarden/stuck_tree.jpg : Stucking in tree possible
http://demolite.climbers-germany.de/mapcheck/trc_climbgarden/vertex_tree1.jpg
http://demolite.climbers-germany.de/mapcheck/trc_climbgarden/vertex_tree2.jpg
http://demolite.climbers-germany.de/mapcheck/trc_climbgarden/vertex_tree3.jpg : Vertexbugs on the trees (a few samples)

- SC (3ddY)
http://files.xtreme-jumps.eu/oO3ddYOo/mapcheck/climbgarden/trc_climbgarden0001.jpg

- bugs: (kzro`CyclopP)
* http://i43.tinypic.com/2vs55b8.jpg | http://i43.tinypic.com/344ayxt.jpg | http://i41.tinypic.com/2q9gv8x.jpg | http://i41.tinypic.com/okbbsk.jpg | http://i42.tinypic.com/1t6ix1.jpg | http://i41.tinypic.com/2qntla9.jpg | http://i39.tinypic.com/14wzhie.jpg | http://i40.tinypic.com/35iyyac.jpg | http://i41.tinypic.com/17sl6s.jpg | http://i39.tinypic.com/2mhv8mp.jpg | http://i41.tinypic.com/2i89ipx.jpg | http://i44.tinypic.com/qyitsy.jpg | http://i39.tinypic.com/jhbm77.jpg | http://i41.tinypic.com/2qvh4d3.jpg | http://i44.tinypic.com/2e1gnz4.jpg | http://i42.tinypic.com/xku32b.jpg | http://i43.tinypic.com/25fm59e.jpg | http://i39.tinypic.com/6o0dmo.jpg | http://i42.tinypic.com/2ih5yq9.jpg – lightbugs
* http://i39.tinypic.com/2zh4pz9.jpg | http://i39.tinypic.com/2hqxdzb.jpg | http://i39.tinypic.com/wb40li.jpg – texture bug

Suggestions:

- you could add shadows from the walls, would look more realistic.

- make a .res file for your map.

- http://www.zeroup.dk/uploads/1237487649.jpg
http://www.zeroup.dk/uploads/1237545389.jpg
http://www.zeroup.dk/uploads/1237572786.jpg
^ Weird texture transitions. (puppetz)

- Optional:
http://demolite.climbers-germany.de/mapcheck/trc_climbgarden/optional_lightbug.jpg
http://demolite.climbers-germany.de/mapcheck/trc_climbgarden/optional_vertex.jpg

Other:

CONCLUSION:

1. the map is too short! (but its not a big problem, your map will just have a bigger chance to get accepted if its longer)

2. as you can see, we found a lot of bugs, but remember! you dont have to fix all of them, because EVERYTHING is there :P by fixing the worst ones, should give you a YES next time.

Originally posted by tranCyfast

As for shortcuts, http://img21.imageshack.us/img21/4521/trcclimbgardensc2.jpg - I'm not sure if that's even possible (a demo would be nice).

changelog missing, reupload