Poll on demo releases

iLOL__-25/11/2008 02:21

dont forget about the "fans" xD

they will maybe choose only their favorite jumper

25/11/2008 12:47

Originally posted by Igge
Well people have different opinions which is the best WR even if it's easy to say which was the best. It's good to have a poll where everyone can vote.
This post is much better than the last 1 where "best demo of the week" was suggested. With the best demo of the year it's more reasonable with a reward.

I don't like the idea with the best map though. People can judge a WR because they know all things that is hard/easy, such as Supa explains. If you want people to judge maps I think you should teach every member how different maps are created. This is almost impossible and therefor the maps will be judged for its jumps, fps and architecture. Not many people will understand the work behind it. Thats why I think it's unfair to the mappers.

The best WR demo poll should be open to every jumper, which is almost the whole community.

The best map poll should be open to experienced mappers.

Oh right, then demo poll should be open also only to experienced jumpers?

You don't have to know the work behind a map, it only matters if you enjoy the map or not. It's just your opinion. Like when electing a new president, everybody can vote, not just the ones who actually know something about politics.

Murvelman25/11/2008 15:05

It would be good if it worked, but sadly i don't think it would.

TT.26/11/2008 17:37

an other good idea,
but i guess admins wont have time to organize the polls
what a pity
good idea fof!

cHoseN â™¥30/11/2008 11:25

Very good idea

prof. chosen08/12/2008 13:09(edited 08/12/2008 13:09)

i dont like it because most people will vote for their favourite climber i guess.

rainbowcyan08/12/2008 17:10

hmm,vote for the best demo?It is just like xj's weekly,this is a very interesting thing